It was really hard to come up with a description for this group of Judd Apatow/Evan Goldberg group of dudes. The best way I could think of it was "the guys who do Apatow stuff who aren't Will Ferrel or John C Reilly or Brick Tamland and who were on Freaks and Geeks (but are still working)". So...I think I was able to narrow it down to the ones you keep seeing over and over again. I guess the best way to describe this Do, Date, or Dump is Funny Jews who Smoke a Shitload of Weed and Make Weiner Jokes.
Sigh. I just described my future husband. Let's do this!!!
James Franco (Freaks & Geeks, Pineapple Express)
Do, Date, or Dump?
You'd have to be blind not to say Do. James Franco is walking sex; hell, he was wearing sweatpants for most of Pineapple Express, and he was still smoking hot (and you know how I feel about sweatpants). He seems like the kind of guy who would hit it and quit it, which would totally suck - cause you know it's going to be amazing, but he's never going to call you again.
Seth Rogen (Freaks & Geeks, The 40-Year-Old Virgin, Knocked Up, Undeclared, Pineapple Express)
Do, Date, or Dump?
Oh wow, Date for sure (of course we all know date = marry). I wouldn't mind giving up sex if it meant that I could wake up to Seth Rogen every morning (because that's what happens when you get married, people. Sex = Not Happening). Regardless, I would be more than happy to get up early on a Saturday morning and make him waffles. Not Eggos either, but like real-ass waffles.
Jason Segel (Freaks & Geeks, Knocked Up, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, I Love You Man)
Do, Date, or Dump?
DO DO DO DO DO. I have a very unhealthy crush on Jason Segel; he is so fine. And I'm sure that a good 90% of you are sitting at home reading this and yelling out "Oh shit, no!!! He's so gross and flabby and freckly and mole-y and gigantically-Shrek-like and he has moobs!" and you know what? DON'T CARE, STILL WANT.
Jonah Hill (Knocked Up, Superbad, The 40-Year-Old Virgin, Forgetting Sarah Marshall)
Do, Date, or Dump?
It's funny. This summer I was told that a group of people were thinking about people's ideal matches and it was unanimous that my Perfect Soulmate is Jonah Hill. Swoon! I love Jonah Hill and I do think we are very similar, so I'm going to say Date. I'm not totally attracted to him (he is lacking in the freckles department. Moobs, however...) but I think that I would grow to appreciate his charming good looks. Bwahahahaha, I couldn't say that with a straight face. He's fucking weird looking, but he is super funny and adorable, and that's what I'm looking for in a husband.
Martin Starr (Freaks & Geeks, Knocked Up, Superbad)
Do, Date, or Dump?
Do. I would do Bill Haverchuck and I would do Beardo-Martin from Knocked Up. Look people, you know I have some messed-up issues, so why would it surprise you that I'd totally sleep with Martin Starr? Plus, there is something about his voice that is pretty hot (maybe it's the monotone? Maybe I'm atrracted to robots! That would explain those dreams I have about KITT).
Jay Baruchel (Undeclared, Knocked Up)
Do, Date, or Dump?
Dump. I know he's cute and Canadian (so I'm supposed to like him) but I wasn't first introduced to him in Undeclared; it was Popular Mechanics for Kids, when he was like...12 or something. He will always be a pre-teen in my mind, so no thanks - I'm too pretty for jail.
Bill Hader (Superbad, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, Knocked Up)
Do, Date, or Dump?
I've said before that I would totally marry Bill Hader, but you know what? He's getting cocky and he's starting to get popular with the frat crowd, so I'm gonna say Dump. I know, it stings, but it's for my own good.
Paul Rudd (The 40-Year-Old Virgin, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, I Love You Man,
Do, Date, or Dump?
CAN I PLS CHOOSE DO AND DATE?!?!?!?!?! Girls, there isn't ANY of you out there who can't say: "Oh my god, I love Josh! I am majorly, totally, butt-crazy in love with Josh!" and not mean it. Sigh.